Stonewall Inn

12/24/10

Pizza you must try!

by dinnerlady at Citysearch

Great pizza New York style with call ahead service for pizza to go. It has a wonderful homey feel for eat in and a nice place to take families.

They also sell pizza by the slice customized with whatever you want for toppings. They offer fresh salads and large chocolate chip cookies for those with a sweet tooth. Yummy.

Their sister restaurant is just across the parking lot with home cooked food and a full bar & patio when the weather is nice. We come back again & again!

10/12/09

Disappointed at the Stonewall Pizza

by pmcco at Citysearch

We went to the Stonewall Inn a month ago and the pizza was fantastic. The crust was perfect, it was busy but the service was good. We went again this weekend, not busy, took 30 minutes to get our pizza (we noticed the person at the counter kept leaving and going to the Stonewall Inn or somewhere... leaving customers standing at the front desk), and when we got our pizza it was not cooked all the way through. We were going to send it back but it took so long to get our food, and the counter girl was gone again, that we just left it. We may go back to give them another try... but was very disappointed in our last visit.

• Pros: Could be good but not consistant
• Cons: slow service

04/25/07

By-the-Slice Pizza as an Art Form - Inexpensive and TASTY!

by almoagnadna at Citysearch

This is the best by-the-slice place I've ever been. It's the only pizza place that can please both me and my significant other - everything from pepperoni, jalapeno & pineapple to good old sausage & pepperoni.

It's not a big place, but if you go during low-traffic times, it's a great, friendly, almost-dive place to eat & have drinks. It's a Johnson County favorite for us!

• Pros: Inexpensive, Unlimited Choices, Friendly Bar Staff
• Cons: I've had TERRIBLE service from most of the waitstaff.

01/12/06

User review by rmmb

by rmmb at Citysearch

Best pizza I've ever had. I rate it above all the pizza places that I've ever eaten at (and that's a lot!). I'm not a sausage fan, but Joe, the owner, said he special orders the sausage and has it flown in -- it's fantastic. You have to try the house special. Not much seating, but a charming place with a quiet laidback atmosphere.

• Pros: Fantastic pizza, small cozy seating
• Cons: closes early, limited beverage menu

07/04/04

The Pizza is Awesome!

by mstoebner at Citysearch

The pizza here is the best!, it's made New York Style, thin crust and loaded with cheese, they sell pizza by the slice during lunch, I usually get carryout because of the somewhat limited seating and that it looks as if has not been remodeled since 1979, but I guess that's part of it's charm.

• Pros: Superb Pizza
• Cons: , a bit run down